Putting the power of Digital Loyalty into your product development strategy

Alexander Tadlock
Manuel Gattinger
Sayori Mukherjee

by Alexander Tadlock, Manuel Gattinger, Sayori Mukherjee

Digital loyalty solutions for product strategy R1hbapm

All of today’s OTT platforms, such as Hulu, HBO Max, Amazon Prime Video and Netflix, bring variety at a hugely competitive price point. Netflix, in particular, boasts around 100 million subscribers globally who share their accounts between multiple users. Yet this popular platform recently took a hit on its stock prices due to a steep decline in its subscription base. Its decision to increase the subscription cost had the company lose 600,000 customers in North America. Additionally, the termination of Netflix services in Russia had cost the platform another 700,000 subscribers.

Retention is ultimately a result of customer satisfaction that comes through holistic product development. When customers feel valued by a product or service, they will become more likely to stay, which is what loyalty is in a nutshell. Customer retention extensively contributes to the sustainable growth of any business; with a retention rate of 5%, a company is able to increase its profits by 25% to 95%. It’s important to take into account that today, on average, users take only 10-20 seconds to make decisions online. Moreover, 77-80% of customers have experienced new shopping behaviors through different channels since the pandemic. 

Digital Loyalty Product development strategy

Hence, what are the key factors behind preserving loyalty in the product development process considering today’s highly competitive digital landscape? Let’s explore them now.

Traditional vs. Digital Loyalty

As more customer-facing businesses go digital, so does the approach of loyalty programs. However, the basic structure of the loyalty programs is still essentially the same, such as:

  • Tiered loyalty: Within these programs, customers earn different levels of rankings or exclusive status — with or without points. This makes it unique from point-based programs, and Sephora’s Beauty Insider program offers one of the best examples for how to achieve this. Within their 3-tiered approach, members and customers with higher status can earn experiential rewards, instead of pure points rewards, such as being the first in line for new product launches, restocks and other free or limited-edition products/services. 
  • Point-based loyalty: This loyalty type enables customers to accumulate points that can be redeemed for rewards or free products/services. An innovative loyalty program that does this is called Blumetopia, created by body care retailer Blume. In this, Blume pioneered a points system called Blume Bucks, and consumers can earn these Blume Bucks in a variety of ways by putting in an order, leaving reviews or engaging with the brand via its social media pages. Together with gamification methods, Blume brings its customers on a digital adventure that gets them excited for engaging more with the brand. 
  • Paid loyalty: Customers pay a recurring subscription fee, monthly or annually, for great benefits they can use immediately and at any time throughout the subscription duration. Barnes & Noble has been effective in their paid loyalty program with a $25 annual fee for VIP membership, in which members enjoy free shipping, special birthday offers, and early access and discounts. The key takeaway for programs like these is to focus on marketing towards your existing customer base, since new customers may not be interested, and exclusive benefits to members must be included.
  • Value-based loyalty: By associating itself with programs supporting social causes, brands connect with their customers at a deeper level. It also allows customers to have access to value-added services. TOMS, one of the biggest shoe manufacturers and retailers worldwide, offers this in a real way through their One for One loyalty program–where customers get non-monetary incentives for any of their purchases. When they purchase shoes, a pair of shoes is donated to a community in need; and most recently, every purchase of TOMS now helps fund access to mental health resources to the millions of people who need them. This model illustrates how loyalty doesn’t always have to be in the form of money and, instead, can appeal to the customer’s ethics and self-image. 

How brands choose and combine loyalty programs depends on their short- and long-term digital product strategies. Monetization from loyalty programs would traditionally be the result of when the customer makes a transaction. Yet such types of engagement severely limit the opportunity to deliver an emotional high. Today, the versatility of digital interaction and its ability to connect between different touch points allow brands to frequently engage with the customers.

Digital loyalty - customer engagement

Source: antavo.com

Key digital product strategies that win big on loyalty programs

Now let’s take a deeper look at today’s digital landscape – and, more importantly, the key opportunities for harnessing long-term customer loyalty. A few of the world’s most profitable and enduring brands have put these strategies to practice and yielded overwhelming success.

We’ll break down two key opportunities, adaptable to any company’s digital strategy, and how they can be incorporated within a time-tested product development framework.

Building a community by gamification

Starbucks, especially in the US, has shown how good they are at integrating multiple touch-point loyalty programs into their digital product development. They’ve done it by utilizing customer data and AI to create personalized engagement strategies to get their customers hooked. With a combination of point-based and tiered loyalty programs, Starbucks has provided its customers the access to exclusive games and personalized offers. It has leveraged on gamification to make their engagements attractive and entertaining. Gabe Zichermann in his talk at Talks at Google says that gamification brings ‘intrinsic reinforcement’ that engages users to address challenges and focus on winning, which leads to a sense of achievement and, thus, satisfaction.

Effective personalization and customer-centered user experience

Amazon’s expertise in appropriate personalization, usage of omnichannel and efficient service delivery capacity helped them to retain 90% of its customers during the pandemic. While paid loyalty is competitive, Amazon has successfully utilized technology within its product development strategy to personalize customer experience in a way that has worked towards strengthening its customer base. Furthermore, the Prime Day event creates a sense of ‘FOMO’ (or ‘Fear Of Missing Out’) among people who are not part of the Amazon community. It has paid attention to keep its user experience on the digital platform and the experience in-between touchpoints extra simple, straightforward and thoroughly customer-centered.

Best practices for the product development process

To design digital products and services at Star, we’ve created a product development framework that allows us to make better decisions in driving Digital Loyalty among the diverse and tech-savvy users for their respective brands. 

Product development framework


Get to know your customers: Within any product development strategy, it’s good to create feedback loops in the customer journey for the customers to provide their feedback. This system brings engagement and opportunity for product and service development. Furthermore, it motivates the users to gain more trust in the product/service when they see their feedback taken into consideration. This has potential to be further translated into referral opportunities. 

Transform mistakes into opportunities: Making mistakes could also be a leverage point for loyalty if it is seen as an opportunity. For instance, a customer has complained after receiving a damaged product. As a response, the brand not only provides a smoother return but also rewards the customer for their patience. Such a service recovery mindset within digital product development fosters a strong and trustworthy relationship between the two parties, additionally increasing the chances of referral.

Loyalty programme strategy


Data insight implementation: The relationship between the brand and its customers is no different than when two people meet and slowly become friends. Brands often tend to under-utilize their 1st-party data that provides the most effective way to understand their customers, including their unique needs at a deeper level of engagement. Deriving appropriate insights from the available user data and actively planning the implementation of these insights within the brand ecosystem are the most common challenges for brands during their product development process. That means mastering a strategic use of data and focusing on user-centricity are important keys to sustainable customer engagement, hence growth.


Make it fun like a game: For any brand, the need of the hour is to be adaptive, agile and creative, considering the rapid growth of e-consumers. The combination of omnichannel and gamification is a powerful digital strategy to shape shorter but seamless and emotionally intelligent experiences, as it’s important to not get customers bored with long and repetitive engagement patterns. What works best is frequent short-spanned engagements that keep the users involved and build multiple experiences worth being part of.

Nurture the team and the brand: Emotional intelligence is on the rise. In order to achieve a holistic transformation, equal attention should be given to nurturing the people associated and working with the brand. It’s people that make a product evolve into a memorable service, not to mention with the help of technology. An unhappy employee behind the counter can never serve with compassion. Hence, it’s also important to be empathetic at an organizational level while also training employees on what it means to be customer-centric in all aspects of their interactions.

In this digital landscape, loyalty is measured by the way customers feel being associated with the brand. Accuracy in personalization highly depends on the way data and insights are dealt with. Empathy is the lens to find the right gaps. As a result, the meticulous ways of research and usage of design methods can significantly help foster Digital Loyalty among users. 

Customers are always loyal to their needs. Therefore, the only way to go is to put individual customers front and center while designing any product-driven services.

Co-creating loyalty in every product development strategy

These days, the best way for a product or service to be truly disruptive is through high customer retention. In the recent 2022 Loyalty Report, 72% of respondents said loyalty programs are part of their relationships with brands and 74% said they’re more likely to recommend brands with good loyalty programs. This highlights why it’s critical that the product development process for companies, large and small, focuses on Digital Loyalty solutions.

Star’s universal framework – learn, understand, evolve – offers the foundation needed for starting or reimagining your products in line with this globally competitive digital ecosystem. Customer expectations of the products and services they use are ever-rising – which is why we make sure a company’s purpose closely aligns with its customer values through next-gen digital product strategy. From ideation to product launch, our collaborative team of strategists, designers, developers and engineers thrives on working closely with its partners every step of the way — and evolving together to ensure long-term customer loyalty.

Digital loyalty solutions for product strategy Ralkbapm
Alexander Tadlock
Senior UX/UI Designer at Star

Alexander is a Mexican/American UX/UI designer & Illustrator with a passion for creating delightful digital products that are relevant to people and creating meaning around brands. Alexander has a strong background in storytelling, conceptualization and character design/illustration. He believes that every brand has the power to unleash a creative and appealing message to its target audience.

Digital loyalty solutions for product strategy Rapkbapm
Manuel Gattinger
Head of Design, Germany at Star

Manuel strives to make complex things more democratic and to design and build solutions that have a positive impact. He has more than 15+ years of experience in the field of user-centered innovation and with projects where strategy, design and technology intersect. Manuel is part of the iF Design Jury and an active lecturer for UX-Design at the Macromedia University of Design.

Digital loyalty solutions for product strategy Ratkbapm
Sayori Mukherjee
UX Design Intern at Star

Sayori comes with five years of experience in branding and visual communication design with a keen eye for building narratives. She’s currently shaping her career as a strategic and user experience designer with a service design approach. As her design expertise continues to grow, Sayori is always driven to create impactful and user-centered, screen-based and beyond-screen experiences.

Harness the future of technologies

Star uses top-notch technology solutions to create innovative digital experiences for our clients.

Explore our work
North America, Big

We are truly global.
Explore our locations around the world.

North America, Big

Star is a global technology consulting firm that seamlessly integrates strategy, design and engineering as an end-to-end partner on its clients’ digital journeys. Star’s unique approach helps rapidly expanding startups and established enterprises reach their endgames while prioritizing empathy for the end-users, society, and the planet.

Insights & inspiration

Receive the latest Star insights on trends, technologies and endgame-driven approaches straight to your inbox.


Or write us at hello@star.global

© Copyright Star 2024. All rights reserved Privacy Policy

plus iconminus iconarrow icon pointing rightarrow icon pointing rightarrow icon pointing downarrow icon pointing leftarrow icon pointing toparrow icon pointing top rightPlay iconarrow pointing right in a circleDownload iconResume iconCross iconActive Badge iconInactive Badge iconFocused Badge iconDropdown Arrow iconQuestion Mark iconFacebook logoLinkedin logoLinkedIn logoFacebook logoTwitter logoInstagram logo